City of Roanoke Prevails; Railroad Must Pay Stormwater Management Fee
On February 15, 2019, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the City of Roanoke’s Stormwater Management Utility charge was a regulatory fee and not a tax. The Court, therefore, affirmed the dismissal of Norfolk Southern’s Complaint asserting that the City’s Stormwater Management Utility charge was a tax that discriminated against railroads in violation of federal law. The decision forecloses federal court challenges to local government charges for stormwater management services as unlawful discrimination against railroads. The Court’s decision included three separate opinions; each of the three judges on the panel wrote an opinion. The opinion joined by all […]





